Payments

If you are receiving your insurance premium notices directly from your insurance company, you should remit payment directly to them in the envelope provided with your statement. All other premium payment notices should be sent to out office. Payments to our office can be either mailed or faxed. Please include a copy of your invoice in order that the payment is correctly applied. Listed below are the insurance companies that offer direct payment. You may also call them with any questions you have regarding your statement. Of course, you can always call our office if you would prefer to speak to one of our customer service representatives.

Business Insurance:

CNA Insurance Co.
(877)-276-7507
PO Box 790094, St Louis, MO 63179-0094

Dryden Mutual Insurance Co.
(800)-694-8271
PO Box 635, Dryden, NY 13053

Erie & Niagara Insurance Co.
(800)-234-9876
8800 Sheridan Dr, PO Box 9062, Williamsville, NY 14231-9062

Hanover Insurance Co.
(800)-922-8427
PO Box 580045, Charlotte, NC 28258-0045

Harleysville Insurance Co.
(800)-338-8301
PO Box 37712, Philadelphia, PA 19101-5012

The Hartford Insurance Co.
(866)-467-8730
PO Box 2907, Hartford, CT 06104-2907

Michigan Miller Insurance Co.
(517)-482-6211
Department 208301, PO Box 55000, Detroit, MI 48255-2083

New York Central Mutual
(800)-234-6926
1899 Central Plaza E, Edmeston, NY 13335

Peerless Insurance Co.
(800)-542-5385
PO Box 2051, Keene, NH 03431

Philadelphia Insurance Co.
(800)-759-4961
PO Box 70251, Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251

Progressive Insurance Co.
(800)-888-7764
PO Box 94739, Cleveland, OH 44101

Safeco Insurance Co.
(877)-566-6001
PO Box 6476, Carol Stream, IL 60197

 

Selective Insurance Co.
(973)-948-3000
Box 371648, Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468

NY State Insurance Fund
(877)-309-6028
P.O. Box 9204, New York, NY 10087-9204

Tower Group Companies
(877)-883-6599
PO Box 29919, New York, NY 10087-9919

Travelers Insurance Co.
(800)-252-2268
CL Remittance Box 660317, Dallas, TX 75266-0317

Utica First Insurance Co.
(800)-456-4556
PO Box 851, Utica, NY 13503

Utica National Insurance Co.
(800)-274-1914
PO Box 530, Utica, NY 13503

Zurich Insurance Co.
(800)-800-3907
8712 Innovation Way Chicago, IL 60682-0087

Personal Insurance:

 

Auto One Insurance Co.
(866) 252-4669
PO Box 9025 Melville NY 11747

Dryden Insurance Co.
(800) 694-8271
12 Ellis Drive Dryden NY 13053

Erie & Niagara Insurance Co.
(800) 234-9876
8800 Sheridan Dr PO Box 9062 Williamsville NY 14231

Farmers Insurance Co.
(888)-883-2798
PO Box 0913 Carolstream Ill 60132-0915

Foremost Insurance Co.
(800) 527-3905
PO Box 0915 Carolstream Ill 60132-0915

GMAC Insurance Co.
(800)-729-0122
PO Box 1018 Winston Salem, NC 27107

Hanover Insurance Co.
(800) 922-8427
PO Box 580045 Charlotte NC 28258-0045

Harleysville Insurance Co.
(800) 338-8301
PO Box 37712 Phila PA 19101-0512

The Hartford Insurance Co.
(800) 624-5578
PO Box 2907 Hartford, CT 06104-2907

Kemper Insurance Co.
(800) 327-1500
PO Box 550750 Jacksonville, FL 32255

Mercury Insurance Co.
(800) 503-3724
Auto: POBox 11995 Santa Anna, CA 92711;
Home: POBox 5600 Rancho Cucamota, CA 91729

Metropolitan Insurance Co.
(800) 680-3354
PO Box 41753 Philadelphia PA 19101         eservice: www. eservice.metlife.com

National Grange Insurance Co.
(877) 927-5672
PO Box 2004 Keene, NH 03431

New York Central Mutual Insur. Co.
(800) 234-6926
1899 Central Plaza East Edmeston, NY 13335-1899

Peerless Insurance Co.
(866) 223-9928
PO Box 703 Keene, NY 03431

Progressive Insurance Co.
(877) 776-2436
Dept 0561 Carol Stream, IL 60132

Safeco Insurance Co.
(877) 566-6001
PO box 6476 Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476

Travelers Insurance Co.
(877)872-8737
PO Box 660307 Dallas TX 75266-037

Utica First Insurance Co.
(800) 456-4556
PO Box 851 Utica, NY 13503-0851

Utica National Insurance Co.
(800) 274-1914
Credit & Collections UNIBILL, PO Box 530, Utica, NY 13503